Saturday, February 14, 2009

Gold Precious Metals ETF

Best gold ETF?A common way to invest in gold and other precious metals without having to physically store it yourself is through an ETF. ETF stands for exchange-traded fund. It is like a mutual fund that is traded on a stock exchange like a stock, and can be bought and sold very simply through any trading platform, even a $6 Scottrade account. ETFs track a stock index like the S&P 500, or an industry, or in this case a commodity, specifically a precious metal like gold or silver. So you buy shares in the fund, and the fund managers invest that money in gold on your behalf. If the value of gold increases, the value of your fund shares increases. When you cash out the fund sells your portion of the gold and gives you your money. Theoretically speaking, that is.

The problem with gold ETFs is that unlike possessing physical gold bullion, you never really know what is happening with your gold. You don't even know if you really have any gold. If you read the fine print of the ETF prospectus you will find some fishy statements, such as the iShares Silver Trust which states that “The iShares are intended to constitute a simple and cost-effective means of making an investment similar to an investment in silver.” What do they mean by "an investment similar to an investment in silver"? That statement clearly shows that not all of your shares are backed by physical silver. They may be backed by cash, they may be backed by a piece of paper that promises to give the fund some silver in the future, but not every share is backed by the physical bullion you intended to invest in. Let's say the fund managers are playing with your Physical gold bullion ETF? B.S.!money in creative ways through futures and whatnot, and make a big mistake and lose all of the fund's assets? The value of your shares could drop like a rock even if the value of gold is skyrocketing at that very moment. That possibility is evident in another quote from the iShares Silver Trust prospectus that says "the liquidity of the iShares may decline and the price of the iShares may fluctuate independently of the price of silver and may fall". There, they admit it. This investment is not an investment in silver, at least not completely. I don't know how likely those independent fluctuations are, but one of the major reasons for holding physical gold is to protect your wealth in times of chaos. But in times of chaos I wouln't be quite uncomfortable holding shares in a trust that is owned by a bank. If that bank decided to shut down the trust and default because they don't have the physical metals to back your shares, what could you do about it? It sounds unlikely, but in times of chaos who knows what will happen. That's the point of having a safe haven investment in physical precious metals.

To read more on some of the questionable conditions of your investment in a gold or silver ETF read James Turk's articles

Unanswered Questions About the Silver ETF

The Paper Game

If you are an active short term trader, ETFs are a reasonable trading vehicle. You can sell your shares easily any time you want, through any trading platform including a discount online brokerage, the buy/sell spread is much more narrow than when buying physical precious metals. The funds basically do follow the movements of the precious metals they are meant to track, so if you plan on making short term trades ETFs are fairly secure. The problem comes through exposing yourself to risk through longterm investment in an ETF. In that case I highly recommend that you be the sole owner of your own physical bullion and personally possess it, either in your home or in a storage facility.

No comments: